Previously we wrote Overview of Sexual Assault and Consent Law in Australia and Cases of International Students Falsely Accused of Domestic Violence or Sexual Assault --Those two articles cover the legal framework and typical cases. But more and more of the clients who come to us for advice are faced with astarker reality:Being called by the police for questioning, being told ”Assisting in the investigation of an allegation of sexual assault.”Received Notice to appear.
In such a scenario, what the accused needs is not ”legal literacy”, but rather.Clear and enforceable legal responses-particularly in NSW June 2022, VIC July 2023Affirmative Consent ((Positive consent)new lawAfter the entry into force, the legal environment facing the accused changed fundamentally.
This post is for people who have alreadyAccused, contacted by the police, or about to face court proceedingsA guide to legal responses written by people who Covers NSW + VIC two states,:: Maintaining a strict ”legal rights of the accused and defence strategies” perspective.
If you are being approached by the police or facing charges -The first thing you should do is not read the article.,Instead, contact a criminal lawyer immediately. This article is to help youUnderstanding your rights and the follow-up procedure, is not a substitute for professional legal representation.
Reference reading:This article is related to our previous A complete guide to responding to being summoned, detained and questioned by the police and Australian Criminal Records Guide Matching use.
Adopted by NSW Crimes Legislation Amendment (Sexual Consent Reforms) Act 2021 revised Crimes Act 1900 (NSW),The core reforms are centred on three articles.
s 61HI.New definition of consent
“A person consents to a sexual activity if., at the time of the sexual activity, the person freely and voluntarily agrees to the sexual activity.”
Note the expression ”at the time of the sexual activity” - it means thatPrior consent does not equal current consent,Separate consent required for each stage of sexual behaviour.
s 61HJ.List of non-consensual situations
Lists anon-exhaustiveThe law has a non-exhaustive list of circumstances in which consent is not given. The accused must be aware that the law does not consider consent to be given even if the other party does not explicitly say ”no” in any of the following cases.
s 61HK.Reasonable belief in consent
this is Affirmative Consent Core provisions of the reform:
“A person's belief that another person consents to a sexual activity is not reasonable if the person did not, within a reasonable time before or at the time of the sexual activity., say or do anything to ascertain whether the other person consented.”
Translation into substantive languages.The defendant must take the initiative to do or say something to confirm the other party's consent -Otherwise its”I thought the other guy agreed.”beliefs that are not legally considered reasonableThis article directly abolishes the traditional logic of ”passively waiting for the other side to resist”. This article directly abolishes the traditional defence logic of "passively waiting for the other side to resist".
VIC through Justice Legislation Amendment (Sexual Offences and Other Matters) Act 2022 revised Crimes Act 1958 (Vic),The core provisions include.
s 36.Agree with the definition From “free agreement” to “free and voluntary agreement”- reinforces the dual requirement of `freedom” and `voluntariness”.
s 36AA.List of non-consensual situations Similar to NSW s 61HJ, but VIC additionally puts the stealthing(removal, destruction or non-use of a condom without consent) is explicitly listed as a non-consensual situation (s 36AA(1)(o)), the first state in Australia to explicitly include stealthing in its law.
s 36A.Reasonable belief in consent It is also required that the accused must actively do or say something to confirm consent, otherwise his or her belief is not considered reasonable.
Prior to the new law, common defences for the accused included.
Under the new law.,These defences are largely ineffective. The defendant must prove that he or she, before or at the time of the commencement of the sexual actdo sth of one's own accordDid or said something to confirm the other person's agreement - e.g..
significant:: New lawNo complete reversal of burden of proof--The prosecution must still prove that the defendant ”knew, recklessly, or with an unreasonable belief” that the other party did not consent. But the new lawIt's tightening up.”Reasonable Faith”Definition of-Makes it difficult for the accused to plead ”I thought I agreed”.
Substantive results.The prosecution is more likely to reach beyond reasonable doubt of the criteria, the,Significant narrowing of the defence space for the accused.
The new law specifies that.self-induced intoxication(Self-induced intoxication)It can't be used as a defence.”I was drunk so I didn't initiate the enquiry”In other words. In other words, the accused cannot use the defence that ”I was also drunk and I did not notice that she did not agree”.
This article is of particular interest toAllegations in the party sceneEspecially critical - when both parties are drunk - is the fact that the accusedcannotExonerated because he was also drunk.
NSW in Criminal Procedure Act 1986 (NSW) Five new jury instructions have been added, requiring the judge to inform the jury at trial that.
These instructionsFurther limiting theThe traditional ”challenge to the credibility of the victim” strategy of defence counsel.
For persons accused of sexual assault, police contact is usually initiated in the following manner.
Either way.,What you should do immediately is:
First.Do not answer any substantive questions
The police may ask.
The answer to all these questions is:
“I want to speak to a lawyer before answering any questions.” (I want to contact a lawyer before answering any questions.)
See our A complete guide to responding to being summoned, detained and questioned by the police -The full logic of police interrogation response applies equally to sexual assault allegations.
Secondly.Don't try.”Proactive Clarification”
In the case of sexual assault allegations.,The most common and the deadliest.The pitfall is the defendant's ”voluntary clarification”. Common words.
Any of these statements could be crucial evidence for a conviction under the new law.. “She was also drunk” - may directly assist the prosecution in proving the other party's incapacity to consent; “I thought she consented” - - is no longer a valid defence under the new law, but instead becomes an admission that you did not initiate the questioning.
Thirdly.Contact a criminal lawyer today
Sexual assault allegationsabsolutely notHandle it yourself. Find Now.
There are two key differences between NSW and VIC procedures for alerting to sexual assault cases that the accused should be aware of.
dimension (math.) | NSW | VIC |
Length of detention | 6-hour base investigation period (LEPRA s 115), extendable by 6 hours | “Reasonable time” standard, no hard cap |
Exceptions to the right to silence | s 89A Silence may be prejudicially presumed in serious indictable offence + physical presence of counsel + special caution | No similar exception to s 89A, more complete protection of right to silence |
Video requests | LEPRA s 281 Forced video recording | Crimes Act 1958 s 464H Forced Video |
translation rights | Provided through TIS National (free of charge) | s 464D Explicit requirement for qualified translators |
For details on interstate differences and coping strategies, refer to our Guidelines for Responding to Police Interrogations.
If the police decide to do a formal ”record of interview” with you, you have two options.
Option 1.Silence throughout (no comment interview)
this isThe overwhelmingly recommended choice of criminal lawyers. You will answer only identifying information (name, address, date of birth) and answer “no comment” to all substantive questions.
Option 2.Interrogation (on the advice of a lawyer)
This only applies in a very small number of cases - usually when the attorney evaluates that there areClear alibiorStrong factual defenceIt can be built from the start.
crux:: This decisionYou shouldn't have to do it yourself.The lawyer will assess the situation and tell you which one you should choose. When the lawyer arrives, he or she will assess the situation and tell you which one to choose.
In NSW and VIC, the process after being charged is basically similar, but there are detailed differences.
When the police decide to prosecute, you will be served with.
Common Types of Charges for Sexual Assault Related Offences (NSW) Crimes Act 1900):
VIC Crimes Act 1958 Similar.
Bail decisions in sexual assault casesMore complex than normal criminal cases:
See our The Complete Guide to Bail in Australia and Bail Bonds Surety Application Guidelines.
Bail in sexual assault caseseasilyStrict conditions apply, commonly including.
Breach of any of the bail conditions will result in bail Cancelled and imprisoned--This is the most common minefield for defendants in sexual assault cases.
Sexual assault allegations (especially sexual assault and rape) are usually indictable offences(serious indictable offences), the case is eventually heard in District Court (NSW) or County Court (VIC), but there is an intermediary process. Local Court / Magistrates’ Court committal proceedings:
The Committal stage isKey points in defence strategy-Lawyers can.
If the case is transferred to District Court / County Court, the hearing usually lasts 1-3 周,may include.
In the sexual assault trial, the accusedWhether or not to testify in courtIt's in the defence strategy.toughest decision--This must be assessed by an experienced defence lawyer.
point | Duration (typical) |
The police questioned Charge. | 1 day - weeks |
Charged to first Local Court appearance | 2-6 weeks |
Committal procedure | 3-12 months |
Transferred to District/County Court and then to trial | 6-18 months |
From charged To trial total time | Usually 12-24 month |
Under the new law on Affirmative Consent, the path of defence for the accused has been significantly narrowed butThere are still several legitimate lines of defenceThis section objectively explains which defences are still valid under the new law. This section objectively explains which defences are still valid under the new law.
If the direction of your defence is “This never happened.”(complete denial), that defenceNot affected by the new law--Because the new law changes the definition of ”consent” and does not change the determination of ”whether or not the act took place”.
This defence relies on.
Key reminders:: Until counsel has assessed.,will notAssert yourself that ”I wasn't there” or ”nothing happened” - any statement may be used by the police as follow-up evidence. Have a lawyer assess the strength of your alibi.
In some cases, behaviour at the factual level may not constitute sexual intercourse, sexual touching or sexual act in the legal sense, for example.
If the behaviour that actually occurred does not meet these statutory definitions - the lawyer can apply to have the charge downgraded or dropped.
The sexual assault charge requires the prosecution to prove the defendant'scriminal intent-Based on NSW Crimes Act s 61HK, the prosecution must prove that the accused.
under the new law”Reasonable Faith”The standards have been tightened.--with one key exception.cognitive impairment or mental illness(Cognitive impairment or mental illness) may constitute an exception if it is a ”substantial reason” for the defendant's failure to voluntarily confirm his consent. (NSW Crimes Act s 61HK(3) / VIC Crimes Act s 36A(3))。
take note of:: Self-induced intoxicationNot really. Cognitive impairment.--This exemption cannot be used in party intoxication situations.
Although the new law requires the accused to be ”proactive”, the new law does not require the accused to be "proactive".No specific form prescribed. It is a defence if the accused in fact has evidence of active questioning or observation of non-verbal signals.
crux:: Evidence of such a defenceMust be real and verifiable--The discovery of any forged or post-fabricated ”evidence” would make the case worse, possibly triggering the perjury (perjury) In addition, the Government has also brought additional charges (up to 14 years' imprisonment) against the Government of the United States of America for the offence of "criminal offence".
This line of defenceSeverely restricted under the new law--The new jury directions clearly inform the jury that.
ButThere are still several legitimate credibility challenge angles:
This direction must be handled with great care by experienced defence counsel--The slightest mistake could be perceived by the jury as ”victim shaming”, resulting in an increased sentence.
In cases of sexual assault.,A lot of cases end up in plea bargaining. Settlement,Instead of a full trialThis is a reasonable option for the defendant. This is a reasonable option for the accused and needs to be assessed under the guidance of counsel.
Reduced to a lesser offence:
Partial dismissal of charges:
Impact on sentencing:
Consider plea bargain present situation:
No plea bargain. present situation:
对Temporary visa holders,PRNon-naturalised persons,The logic of ,plea bargainUnlike Australian citizens.:
In other words, for a non-citizen, “taking a plea bargain and getting six months” imprisonment” and ”trial and losing and getting 18 months' imprisonment" - the former preserves your status in Australia, the latter means deportation. The former preserves your status in Australia, the latter means deportation. This is a key decision that a lawyer must help you assess.
Core recommendations for non-citizens:Find a lawyer who understands both criminal defence and immigration law--Mere criminal lawyers may not understand the knock-on effect of plea bargain on visas. For more information AHL Legal Criminal Defence Services and Immigration legal services.
If the case eventually reaches the sentencing stage (after a plea of guilty or conviction), the court will consider a number of factors in determining the sentence.
Sexual assault charges are almost impossible to obtain Section 10 Release without conviction--unless it is a combination of very minor sexual touching allegations + very minor circumstances on the part of the accused + strong mitigating factors.
See our Complete Guide to Spent Conviction and Section 10.
Courts in serious cases often require Pre-Sentence Report--Written by Community Corrections Officer, assessing the defendant.
The defendant shouldfitThis assessment - refusing to cooperate or displaying hostility significantly increases sentencing.
Convicted sex offenders are listed in.
Registration will bring.
Chinese defendants who are not proficient in English face particularly high risks in sexual assault charges--Because.
Critical response:
for further details, refer to Guidelines for Responding to Police Interrogations Section VI. Right to translation.
False accusations of sexual assault do exist--It is true that in some of the cases we have dealt with, the evidence ultimately showed that the accuser's statements were untrue. Butcrux:
We've written about it before. Cases of International Students Falsely Accused of Domestic Violence or Sexual Assault - - can be used as a specific reference for this scenario.
This section is particularly important for all non-Australian citizens.
Consequences of convictions for sexual assault-related offences under the visa regimeFar more serious than the criminal penalties themselves:
criminal charge | Typical imprisonment | s 501 Trigger? | Visa consequences |
Sexual Touching (NSW s 61KC) | 1-3 years | 是(possible) | Highly unlikely to be cancelled |
Sexual Assault (NSW s 61I) | 5-14 years | inevitable | Mandatory cancellation + repatriation |
Aggravated Sexual Assault (NSW s 61J) | 7-20 years | inevitable | Mandatory cancellation + repatriation |
for further details, refer to Character Testing s 501 Guide.
For non-citizens.,Core objectives of the defence.
A common scenario with Chinese clients: the defendant ”doesn't want his family to know” andRefusal to tell parents、Unwilling to cooperate with lawyers in preparing a full defence、A hasty guilty plea for a speedy conclusion.
It's an extremely dangerous choice... The impact of the sexual assault allegation case wasdecades-A hasty decision to plead guilty could cost you your Australian status, be placed on a registration database, and affect all future careers and relationships.
Rational recommendations:Embarrassment of the moment vs. The next few decades of life,What is the lesser of these two things? If the family truly loves you - they are more interested in knowing the truth and supporting you than waiting until they see you deported years later and see the registration records to realise it happened.
Cases of alleged sexual assaultnecessarilyFind a lawyer who.
Attorney's fees in sexual assault casesSignificantly higher thanGeneral criminal cases.
Cases of alleged sexual assaultusually meets Legal Aid norm(as imprisonment may be involved).
Against non-citizen defendants:Strongly recommendedHire a private lawyer at your own expense - Legal Aid Lawyers may not be familiar with visa knock-on effects.
Cases of sexual assault allegations have a tremendous psychological impact on the accused - anxiety, depression, and suicidal thoughts are all common.It's not weakness.,It's a real reaction..
Absolutely not.:
If you are facing or about to face sexual assault charges - act in the following order.
Today (24) hours):
This week (7 days):
The next few months.:
Sexual assault charges are something any accused can face.One of the most serious legal challenges--The space for the defence of the accused has been significantly narrowed, particularly under the new law on affirmative consent. HoweverSerious legal defence still exists--provided youin the first moments (of sth happening)Make the right choice: silence + lawyer + co-operation with legal proceedings.
If you are facing police contact or have been charged--AHL Legal's Criminal Defence Team We can provide a 24-hour emergency response. We have handled a large number of complex sexual assault cases for Chinese clients - from sexual touching to aggravated sexual assault - and are familiar with the defence strategies under the new Affirmative Consent Act. We are familiar with the defence strategies under the new law, and offer Immigration legal services Assess the knock-on effect on visa PR.
emergency contact:Contact Us
not obliged to(unless they present a summons or formal arrest). You can politely decline: “I'm not available right now. Please tell me exactly what it is, and I'll consult an attorney before deciding.” After the attorney's assessment再Decide if, when, and how to communicate with the police.
Absolutely not.Going to a police station without a lawyer to ”assist in an investigation” - any statement may be key evidence in a subsequent prosecution.
Depending on the circumstances.,But the risks are very high.Under the Affirmative Consent New Law. Under the new law on Affirmative Consent.
Seek an attorney immediately - this ”both parties are drunk” scenario is a good example of a defendant under the new Affirmative Consent law.Highest riskOne of the scenes.
It could be favourable evidence.,But not decisive. Under the new law.
Depends on the offence and the sentence. Based on Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 501:
To the PR accused.,Core objectives of the defenceis to avoid 12 months imprisonment + avoid sex offence registration. For more information Character Testing s 501 Guide.
Don't believe it at all.. Australian Policehasn'tThe power to reduce sentences, not to prosecute, or to ”mitigate” - these are the powers of the public prosecutor (DPP) and the judge. The ”commitment” of the police is legallyNot binding in any way.
The only exception isFormal, lawyer-assisted plea bargain--This is legally valid, but must be done with the participation of a lawyer.
for further details, refer to Guidelines for Responding to Police Interrogations.
Sexual assault cases are no place to save money--But there are several options.
Business Scope
Contact Us