...

Hot Commentary | From New Zealand's amnesty: Three amnesties in Australia's history

 

Preface

Preface

 

 

In retrospect, Australia has rarely offered any type of immigration amnesty, whether for people residing in Australia irregularly, visa overstayers or people working in breach of their visa conditions. The few instances of immigration amnesties occurred decades ago, when the immigration and visa systems were very different from what they are today.

 

Catalysed by the epidemic, there have been calls for the Australian Government to grant visa amnesty to migrants who do not hold valid visas. Proposals for visa amnesty have come from a variety of places, including parties, academics and the National Agricultural Labour Advisory Committee's Agricultural Labour Report. The overriding concerns in response to the impact of COVID19 are labour shortages in the agricultural sector, that people may be reluctant to come forward for COVID19 vaccinations if they fear deportation, and so on.

 

The idea has been rejected by senior government and public service officials. Home Affairs Minister Michael Pezzullo told a Senate assessment hearing in March that an amnesty would “undermine the integrity of Australia's visa system”. But why has Australia tried such an amnesty before?

 

 

 

 Historical Review 

Amnesties 1974-1980

 

In 1974, 1976 and 1980, the Australian Government granted amnesties to visa overstayers or other irregular entrants. These policies gave certain categories of “illegal immigrants” the opportunity to apply for permanent status for a limited period of time, provided, of course, that they met health and character requirements. The rationale behind these programmes is usually to manage an undocumented population that may be exploited, have health problems, or contain criminals. Public perceptions of the number of “illegal aliens” and the repeated failure of previous measures to address the problem were also factors. Subsequently, visa exemptions for people in Australia affected by humanitarian factors in their countries of origin have been described as “amnesties”, but more on humanitarian grounds than as amnesties in the strict sense.

 

The 1974 “dispensation” was announced by Immigration Minister Al Grassby in January 1974 and remained open until 30 June 1974. According to a Senate Evaluation Committee report later that year, only 367 people qualified, most of them deserters.

 

The 1976 Coalition amnesty was seen by Malcolm Fraser as “Coalition policy” prior to the December 1975 election, and was promoted by the Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs, Michael McKellar. The Fraser government also initiated the 1980 Regularisation of Status program; in 1976, 8,614 people applied within the specified time limit, and by 30 June of that year, 5,574 applications had been approved and four rejected.

 

The 1990 Joint Standing Committee on Migration Regulations (JSCMR) Report on Illegal Immigrants in Australia - Balancing Control and Humanitarianism summarises the latter two items:

 

A total of 11,042 applications were received by the Australian Government under the 1980 regularisation of status scheme. By 16 October 1981, 9,734 applications had been processed, of which 217 were ineligible and 8 rejected.

 

In a report on visa issuance, the Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs, Ian Macphee, stated that the Government would legislate to restrict the categories of residents who are eligible to change their residence status from temporary to permanent while in Australia. By including this measure in the Migration Act 1958, the Government aims to effectively exclude any future amnesty, which would require further legislation.

 

 

 

 

 Early 1990s 

Not an amnesty

 

The JSCMR report noted that “the Australian Government is firmly opposed to further amnesties and has been supported by the Commission.” For example, the 1987 Australian Migration Policy Advisory Committee (Fitzgerald Inquiry) stated that “the Government has ruled out amnesty powers for illegal immigrants”.

 

As a result of the FitzGerald Inquiry's report of June 1988, Australia's immigration legislation was significantly amended from 19 December 1989, replacing a range of ministerial and administrative “discretionary” arrangements with a regulatory framework.The 1989 reforms included severe restrictions on the ways in which “illegal immigrants” could seek to regularise their immigration status, such as denying visas on the grounds of family membership of an Australian citizen or permanent resident. "Illegal immigrants" may seek to regularise their immigration status, for example by refusing to apply for a visa on the grounds of having a family with an Australian citizen or permanent resident.

 

The Australian Government has introduced a “grace period” to encourage eligible migrants to apply for status or choose to leave Australia through regularised channels without incurring an entry ban or exclusion period. The “grace period” policy is a continuation of some of the policies under the old system, including on the basis of family ties or force majeure for humane reasons, but not for employment reasons. The “grace period” was extended several times and further measures were taken in December 1993 before it was finally closed.

 

These measures were described as transitional arrangements and concessions for Australian migrants, and ministers (e.g. Robert Ray and Gerry Hand) made it clear: this was not an amnesty.

 

 

 

  Now? The future? 

Current framework

 

In its 2020-21 budget speech, the Australian Department of Home Affairs describes the current visa regime as “maximising compliance with entry and stay requirements through effective and appropriate prevention, deterrence and enforcement programs”.

 

Applicants whose visas have expired or are about to expire and who need assistance in resolving their migration status can access a wealth of information on the Australian Department of Immigration website. There is also a system in place whereby people who do not have a valid visa can still apply for assistance or, in exceptional circumstances, seek a “pardon” from the Minister for Immigration.

 

Overall, the Government has maintained its position on visa compliance as part of Australia's border protection measures and has shown no signs of wanting to change this.

 

 

With 30 years + local Australian practice experience, we know how to maximise your benefits within a limited timeframe.

seo&semtracking