...

Legal Risks of Commercialising Popular IP: A Must-Read Copyright Protection and IP Compliance Strategy for Australian Businesses

Overview

As the world's top film and TV IPs such as Zootopia 2 continue to be released in Australia, the characters, storylines and visual elements are once again stirring up emotions among viewers, leading to a wave of family viewing and social media buzz. You may have already seen a lot of character screenshots, mashups, funny voiceovers and various user-made content on TikTok, Instagram or Xiaohongshu, which fully demonstrates the importance of the characters in the film.Deep penetration of popular film and TV IPs in popular culture.

But behind this passion for creating and sharing lies an often overlooked reality:The hotter the film and TV IP, the higher the legal risk of copyright and trademark. AHL Legal recently came across an enquiry about film and TV rights and commercial IP, in which it was found that - as the topic soars in popularity - businesses, content creators, e-commerce sellers and even offline brands are facing a significant rise in the number ofPotential infringement risk.

In particular, in scenarios involving secondary videos, peripheral designs, marketing campaigns, co-branding activities, character image applications, etc., any unauthorised touching of protected stills, characters, lines or iconic design elements may constitute an infringement of copyright, trademark or trade dress.

If you need further information on business law, IP protection, infringement risk assessment or compliant use programmes, click: General overview of commercial law Get more professional information.

Risks of using popular IP content

After the release of a popular film like Zootopia 2, a large number of creators instinctively use official material for reviews, remixes, and second-creation shorts, while fans spontaneously use screenshots of the characters to create emoticons or accompanying images. In the Chinese context, such non-commercial use seems to be regarded as “fair use” or “natural sharing” by default; however, in the case ofAustralia's Strict Copyright SystemUnderneath, there is a huge legal loophole in this perception.

In Australia, the following elements of popular film and television productions are protected by law:

  • Film footage, clips, lines

  • Character images, names (e.g., Officer Judy, Nick Fox)

  • Background music, sound effects

  • Official posters, promotional material

Unauthorised use of the above material in a public scenario may constituteCopyright Infringement.

AHL Legal Details: The Boundaries of “Fair Use” under Australian Copyright Laws

Australian Copyright Lawhit the nail on the head“Fair Dealing” (Fair Dealing)principle, which allows the use of copyrighted material only for specific purposes, for example:Criticism, review, journalism or pedagogical research.

  • “Film Review” or “Second Short Film”.”: If the creator's use is forcomment or criticiseThe purpose and limited use may be protected by “reasonable handling”.

  • “Commercial promotion”: Once this material has been used forMerchant advertising, shop visuals, business social media contentThe purpose of this becomesBusiness promotion and lead generation. Such commercial purposes will almost alwaysBeyond “reasonable treatment”, the risk of infringement will quickly escalate to “Dual legal issues of ”copyright + trademarks".

In such cases, the legal recourse of the right holder is not limited to compensation, but may also require immediate cessation of use and high legal costs.

“Trademark restrictions on ”parallel imports"

Many businesses often mistakenly believe that “Officially made overseas = no infringement”. But under the Australian legal system, the judgement is not centred on whether the goods are genuine or not:

While Australian copyright law allows parallel imports (i.e., the importation of genuine goods) to some extent, theTrade Marks Act 1995empowers the owner of a locally registered trademark to control the brand image and distribution channels.

Popular IPs Brands like Disney in particular have extremely high requirements for quality control and licensing chains in the local market. As long as a local licence is not granted, even if it is officially licensed, it may be deemed to undermine the rights holder's brand control of the Australian market.

Popular trademarks are registered with Customs (Trade Mark Registration), allowing Customs officers to quickly identify and seize goods entering the market without local authorisation, making “genuine goods seized by Customs” a common legal reality in the import trade.

How do I respond to a lawyer's letter received for IP infringement?

When a business receivesCease and Desist Letter (Cease and Desist Letter) from a reputable IP law firm (e.g. DCC)When not handled properly, it will lead directly to soaring legal costs and adverse consequences.

The most common “missteps” that companies avoid include:

  • Self-explanatory or argumentative: Any unprofessional expression may be deemed to be an admission of infringement and be used in subsequent litigation of the claim.

  • Hasty submission of supply chain information: Leakage of supply chain details may facilitate the right holder's ability to trace additional liability until it is sure of its legal status.

  • Undertaking without examination: Such letters of commitment usually requirePayment of high compensation、Destruction of all infringing goodsmergeCommitment to never import in the future. Once signed, you may be subject to the terms of the undertaking even if there are future legal defences.

The correct response strategy should be:

  1. Remain silent and consult a lawyer immediately: Intervention by lawyers to unify the external calibre.

  2. Unified communication: The lawyer will represent the enterprise and communicate with the right party's law firms to seekSignificant risk reduction and avoidance of high compensationand may in some cases seek to release the goods or mitigate the loss.

AHL Legal Business Law Solicitor: understanding the heat, but also the compliance boundaries

Popular IPs often mean stricter brand protection mechanisms. The more the rights holder invests, the more sensitive the regulation, the quicker the customs response, and the more aggressive the law firm involvement.

AHL Legal advises that before you conduct business, you should take the following steps to do soEx ante compliance and due diligence (Due Diligence): 

  1. Copyright Review: To use any film or video clips or music in your publicity, you must obtain awritten authorisationIf authorisation cannot be obtained, you must ensure that the use is in full compliance with the Australian Copyright Act ** “criticism or comment”. If authorisation cannot be obtained, it must be ensured that it is used in a manner that is fully compliant with the Australian Copyright Act **"Criticism or Comment"的The principle of rational handling** and ensuring that the amount used is minimised.

  2. Supply chain review: Before importing popular IP products, be sure to check whether the supplier can provideLocal Authorisation DocumentInstead of relying on the term “genuine”, ask for a copy. Instead of relying on the term "genuine", demand access toWritten permission from the owner of the local registered trade mark.

  3. Legal cost perception: From start to finish, legal fees for IP litigation in Australia can often run into the hundreds of thousands of dollars. The cost of consulting with a lawyer in advance is a trivial “compliance insurance policy” by comparison.

Respect copyrights, use materials with care, and seek professional advice when necessary., is the best way to protect the business and the creators themselves. If you are inContent creation, commercial promotion, importation or licensing of goodsThere are doubts in terms of the AHL Legal'sBusiness Law Team Bilingual legal advice can be provided in both English and Chinese, so that your business and creative endeavours are always in safe hands.

Picture of William Wong

William Wong

William Wang is the Managing Partner of AHL Legal and has over 20 years of experience in the practice of law, focusing on commercial litigation, criminal law, immigration law and family law. Formerly a solicitor at top law firm Blake Dawson Waldron (now Ashurst) and with extensive immigration practice experience at Fragomen LLC, William founded WB Legal in 2013 and will lead the merger of WB Legal with JB Solicitors in 2023, driving the firm's expansion into regional Australia and the use of legal technology. William has acted in a number of significant cases in the NSW and Federal Courts and is a well-known legal expert in the Australian Chinese community.

FAQ

How much money will I probably have to pay when I receive an infringement lawyer's letter (Cease and Desist Letter)?
There is no fixed amount of compensation, and it usually depends on the nature and scale of the infringement. Rights holders will seek legal fees, the destruction of all infringing goods, and substantial damages based on their loss of market. IP litigation in Australia is extremely costly, with legal fees often running into hundreds of thousands of Australian dollars. Therefore, seeking early legal intervention and avoiding litigation is key to damage control.
I just used a screenshot of the film on social media for an emoji or review, is that considered copyright infringement?
If the use is for the purpose of non-commercial “criticism” or “fair dealing” and the use is limited, it is usually protected under Australian copyright law. However, when used commercially to promote, drive traffic to, or sell a product, even if it's just a screenshot or mash-up, it will be considered a commercial act that goes beyond fair use and constitutes copyright and trade mark infringement.
Why is it that genuine merchandise that I have sourced from official sources gets seized at Australian Customs?
The core reason for this is trade mark law. Australian law gives the owner of a locally registered trade mark the power to control the distribution channels for the brand. Even if the goods are genuine, if they do not enter the Australian market through a locally authorised supply chain (i.e. parallel importation without the permission of the local rights holder), they may still be considered to be a breach of brand control and will be seized by Customs under the trade mark filing mechanism.
What should I do immediately when I receive a customs seizure notice or a letter from my law firm's attorney?
The first step is to remain silent and not to reply, explain or sign any document on your own. Any hasty explanation may be seen as an admission of infringement. You should contact a professional IP lawyer immediately. The lawyer will be responsible for assessing your parallel importation defences, reviewing the legality of customs procedures and negotiating with the rights holder in a uniform manner.
Is there a high risk of getting caught using IP images to drive traffic to my small shop social media?
While rights holders typically prioritise combating large-scale infringement, the risk of small-scale commercial infringement is rising as IP monitoring technology becomes more widespread. Popular IPs, in particular, tend to have more aggressive monitoring systems. You should be more concerned about the consequences than the risks: even small merchants can face significant compensation and the cost of destroying their goods if they are caught.

With 30 years + local Australian practice experience, we know how to maximise your benefits within a limited timeframe.

seo&semtracking