...

How to choose a criminal lawyer in Melbourne? Professional criminal defence guide for Sydney and Melbourne

introductory

Mr. Chen (pseudonym) was woken by a knock at the door in the early hours.

Two plain-clothes police officers stood at the door, requesting to come in to ”have a chat”. They held a search warrant, stating that someone had reported him for transferring funds from the company account.

Mr. Chen had no idea what was going on. He'd never experienced anything like it, nor did he know what his rights were. He let the police into his home and answered their ”few simple questions” - only to find he'd unknowingly admitted a great deal.

Three months later, Mr Chan was formally charged and faces up to ten years in prison.

This is a true story, and it's a scene many of us see every month: most people, when first facing a criminal investigation, have absolutely no idea what their rights are, and this ignorance can change their lives forever.

This article tells you what you need to know if you are investigated for a criminal offence in Melbourne or Sydney, how to protect yourself, and when you should get a lawyer.

Table of Contents

In Australia, criminal procedure operates as follows:

Before going into specific strategies, it's important to understand the basic framework of Australian criminal proceedings. Knowing the process allows you to identify where you can intervene.

Three stages: investigation, prosecution, trial

Phase one: Police Investigation)

This is the stage where problems are most likely to arise. Most people in this stage do not seek legal counsel and instead ”chat” directly with the police. The police have the right to question you, search your residence, seize items, and arrest you. You have the right to have a lawyer present, refuse to answer questions outside the scope of the investigation, and object to search warrants.

Phase Two: Prosecution Decision)Our Criminal Charges Services page

If the police investigation concludes with a decision to prosecute, the case will be transferred to the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). The DPP will review the evidence to decide whether there are sufficient grounds to proceed with the prosecution. If you wish to understand the types of charges,

With detailed explanation.

Stage Three: Trial)

If a case goes to trial, the dispute will be heard in either the magistrates' court or the district/Supreme Court, depending on the seriousness of the offence.

In the police investigation stage: What are your rights?

You have the right to remain silent.

In Australia, you have the right to remain silent when questioned by the police. Anything you say can be used as evidence in court – it's not just confessions that count as evidence, even an offhand remark could be interpreted as an admission of guilt. Therefore, the standard response to the police should be: ”I would like to speak to my lawyer first.”

You have the right to request the presence of a lawyer.Our Bail Application Service page

Before any questioning, search, or interrogation, you have the right to have a solicitor present. This is your absolute right, and the police must allow it. Don't wait until you are ”formally arrested” to seek legal advice – contact a solicitor from the very first time you are questioned. If you wish to understand the process regarding bail,

Can help you understand in advance.

Search Warrant: You Must Cooperate vs. You can refuse

If the police hold a valid search warrant, you can ask to see the scope of the warrant, but generally, you need to cooperate. Without a warrant, the police require your consent to enter your residence.

Video interviewThis is the crucial stage.

In Victoria, police will typically interview you in a Record of Interview room. The video recording of this process is crucial evidence in court. If you say the wrong thing on camera, there is almost no way to retract it. Therefore, before you go into a Record of Interview room, it is essential to prepare with a lawyer.

Applying for bail: How to do it in Melbourne and Sydney

The basic principles of bail

The core issues for bail are: whether you will appear in court on time, and whether you pose a danger to the community. The court will consider the seriousness of the offence, your personal circumstances (e.g., stable address, employment, family ties), and the risk of you absconding.

Applying for bail in Victoria

Bail applications in Melbourne are made to the Magistrates' Court of Victoria. Common bail conditions include surrendering your passport, reporting regularly to a police station, not leaving Victoria or Australia, and not contacting specific individuals. If you breach your bail conditions, bail will be cancelled and you will be re-arrested.

Bail may be refused in a number of circumstances, including: * **Risk of flight:** If the court believes there is a high risk that the defendant will abscond and not appear for their trial or future court dates. * **Risk of reoffending:** If the court believes there is a significant risk that the defendant will commit further offences while on bail. * **Interfering with witnesses or evidence:** If the court believes the defendant might try to intimidate witnesses, tamper with evidence, or obstruct justice. * **Failure to surrender:** If the defendant has failed to appear in court on previous occasions. * **Nature and seriousness of the offence:** For very serious offences, bail may be less likely to be granted. * **Defendant's history:** Previous convictions or a history of breaching bail conditions can weigh against granting bail. * **Public safety:** If releasing the defendant would pose a significant risk to public safety. * **Lack of a suitable address or surety:** In some jurisdictions, bail may be conditional on the defendant having a stable address and/or being supported by a financial guarantor (surety) who can ensure their appearance in court. The specific rules and criteria for refusing bail vary depending on the jurisdiction and the laws in place.

Serious offences are usually more difficult to be granted bail for, such as crimes involving violence, drug trafficking, sexual offences, etc. If your case involves such charges, the involvement of a professional criminal lawyer is even more necessary.

Melbourne vs Sydney: Differences in Criminal Procedure

Item

Melbourne (VIC))

Sydney (NSW))

Jurisdictional court

Magistrates' Court of Victoria

Local Court / District Court

Prosecution service

The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (Victoria)

Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW)

Bail application

Magistrates' Court

Magistrates' Court

Programme features

The system of county lords, cases are handled in a hierarchical manner

District courts and regional courts are tiered.

Chinatown

CBD/Box Hill/Glen Waverley

CBD/Chatswood/Eastwood

The characteristics of criminal procedure in Victoria are as follows: if the offence you are charged with is minor, the case may be heard in the Magistrates' Court by a single magistrate, without a jury. If the offence is more serious, it will be transferred to the County Court or the Supreme Court.

Types of Criminal Charges: Legal Consequences of Common Offences

Drug Offences)

Possession, use, cultivation, and trafficking of drugs – each carries different legal consequences. Victoria's penalties for commercial quantities of drugs are particularly severe, with a maximum sentence of life imprisonment.

Drink driving)

In Victoria, drink-driving is one of the most common criminal charges. Penalties depend on the blood alcohol concentration (BAC) and whether it is a first offence: first offenders may only face fines and licence disqualification, while repeat offenders or high concentrations can lead to imprisonment.

Violence / Assault)

The penalties for violent crimes range significantly, from a common assault to intentionally causing serious injury. Common assault might result in a fine and a community order, while serious violent offences can carry sentences of many years in prison.

Property offences)

Burglary, theft, and robbery all carry different sentencing guidelines. Repeat offenders and property crimes involving violence face harsher penalties.

White-collar crime)

Fraud, embezzlement, and money laundering – these types of crimes typically involve complex financial evidence, requiring the collaboration of specialist legal professionals and expert witnesses with financial backgrounds.

Types of Criminal Charges: Legal Consequences of Common Offences

Drug Offences)

Possession, use, cultivation, and trafficking of drugs – each carries different legal consequences. Victoria's penalties for commercial quantities of drugs are particularly severe, with a maximum sentence of life imprisonment.

Drink driving)

In Victoria, drink-driving is one of the most common criminal charges. Penalties depend on the blood alcohol concentration (BAC) and whether it is a first offence: first offenders may only face fines and licence disqualification, while repeat offenders or high concentrations can lead to imprisonment.

Violence / Assault)

The penalties for violent crimes range significantly, from a common assault to intentionally causing serious injury. Common assault might result in a fine and a community order, while serious violent offences can carry sentences of many years in prison.

Property offences)

Burglary, theft, and robbery all carry different sentencing guidelines. Repeat offenders and property crimes involving violence face harsher penalties.

White-collar crime)

Fraud, embezzlement, and money laundering – these types of crimes typically involve complex financial evidence, requiring the collaboration of specialist legal professionals and expert witnesses with financial backgrounds.

Real-life case: How Mr. Chen went from being sued to being acquitted

Returning to Mr. Chen's story. Mr. Chen answered the police's questions without a lawyer. Three months later, he was charged with three counts and faced a maximum of ten years in prison.

We have done the following:

First: Re-evaluate the evidence

We reviewed the ”confessions” obtained by police during video interrogations and found multiple procedural violations by the police during the recording process, including Mr. Chen not being properly informed of his rights.

Second: Application to exclude illegally obtained evidence
  • We applied to the court to have the video confession excluded from evidence because the police did not fully inform Mr. Chen of his rights before the interrogation began.

Third: Establish counter-evidence
  • We commissioned an independent accountant to review the company’s accounts, which confirmed that Mr. Chan’s actions were duly authorised and did not constitute embezzlement or theft.

Results:

Of the three charges, two were dropped due to inadmissible evidence. The jury found Mr. Chen not guilty on the third charge. Mr. Chen was released from court.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Can I refuse to be questioned by the police?

Yes. You have the right to remain silent when questioned by the police, and you can also ask to speak to a solicitor first. Do not answer questions beyond what is necessary. Remember, just because the police ask ”What did you do?” doesn't mean you have to answer.

You should get a lawyer as soon as possible after you are arrested.

Immediately. The moment the police announce your arrest, you should ask to contact a lawyer. Don't wait until the ”formal interrogation” to start looking for a lawyer – a lot of evidence that is detrimental to you can arise during this initial contact.

How much does a bail application cost?

Bail itself does not incur a fee, but the bail conditions may require you to surrender your passport or pay a bail bond. The bail bond amount is determined by the court, depending on the severity of the case.

What if I don't speak English and the police question me?

You have the right to free interpreter services. In Victoria, police must question you in a language you understand. If you need an interpreter for Mandarin or Cantonese, you must ask.

The approximate cost of criminal lawyers in Melbourne and Sydney varies. However, you can generally expect to pay: * **Hourly rates:** These can range from AUD $250 to AUD $700+ per hour, depending on the lawyer's experience and the complexity of the case. * **Fixed fees:** For specific services like a first court appearance or a bail application, lawyers may offer fixed fees, which could range from AUD $1,000 to AUD $5,000+. * **Full case representation:** For more serious charges that go to trial, the costs can be significantly higher, potentially ranging from AUD $10,000 to AUD $50,000 or more. It's important to note that these are general estimates, and the actual costs will depend on several factors, including: * The seriousness of the charges. * The complexity of the evidence. * The lawyer's level of experience and reputation. * The length and type of court proceedings. * Whether the case is heard in a local court, district court, or supreme court. It is always advisable to get a detailed quote from several different law firms and to clarify exactly what is included in their fees.

The fees depend on the complexity of the case. Simple drink-driving cases might cost a few thousand Australian dollars; for complex drug or white-collar crime cases, legal fees could be tens of thousands of Australian dollars. It is advisable to confirm the fee structure with your lawyer before engaging their services.

If I plead guilty, what are the consequences?

A plea of guilty means you are giving up your right to defend yourself. Sentencing is decided by the judge, and your lawyer can argue for a lighter sentence, but they cannot change the fact of the guilty plea itself. If you plead not guilty, the case will proceed to trial.

With 30 years + local Australian practice experience, we know how to maximise your benefits within a limited timeframe.

seo&semtracking